Why the Senate GRID Savings Act is Better than the House Bill
State legislatures generally set the rules for utility regulation, while corporation commissions / public utility commissions oversee investor-owned utilities and decide their rates and how costs are divided among customers.
In Arizona that’s the Arizona Corporation Commission.
That regulatory system depends on regulators putting the public interest first. In my view, too many of these institutions across the country (including Arizona’s Corporation Commission) have been captured by the industries they’re supposed to regulate. They tend to just rubber stamp rate increases.
That’s why we need federal action to protect regular electricity customers like you and me as giant data centers create enormous new demand for power.
Congress actually does have a couple of proposals that have been proposed. Both address that problem, but there’s a big difference in how they would work.
The House Bill: Consider Protecting Customers
The House’s Ratepayer Protection Act (H.R. 9340) targets new data centers with peak electricity demand of at least 100 megawatts.
The bill suggests that the data centers pay the full added costs of generation, transmission and distribution upgrades needed to serve them.
But – all it really says is that state regulators (e.g. the AZ Corporation Commission for example) would have to consider making them pay full freight but wouldn’t have to adopt it. Basically, there’s no real enforcement.
It strikes me as a bill that makes it seem like congress is acting when it’s really not.
The House passed it 417–3 and the Senate voted 57–43 to advance it last week, which is short of the 60 votes needed to actually vote on it for real. Our Senators both voted no. I would have too.
The Senate Bill: Require Protections
Over in the Senate there is the GRID Savings Act (S. 5199) which is much more enforceable. It covers new or expanded nonresidential electricity demand of at least 150 megawatts. Its most important element, it:
- Establishes enforceable federal rules. Direct FERC (the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission a federal agency that regulates interstate electricity transmission and wholesale electricity) to regulate how data centers connect to the interstate transmission system.
- Makes them pay for their connections. Assign them 100% of the costs of connection facilities and facilities built solely for their use.
- Protects against abandoned projects. Require financial guarantees to prevent unrecovered costs from landing on other customers.
- Requires clear accounting. Discloses facility costs, who pays them and how those costs will be recovered.
- Evaluates alternatives and protect reliability. Considers storage, flexible electricity use and advanced transmission technologies while requiring reliable grid operation.
Why I Like the Senate Bill More
The Senate bill has more regulatory muscle because it requires federal action and doesn’t rely on captured local and state commissions – plus it’s not voluntary compliance like the House bill.
In Arizona, I have little confidence that another instruction to consider protecting customers would produce meaningful change. The GRID Savings Act would make protections within its jurisdiction a requirement rather than a choice.
Summary
Data centers should pay for their own generation infrastructure. The core responsibility to make sure that happens is really at the state and local level – but the Senate Grid Savings Act does a nice job leveraging the fact that electricity in almost all states is interstate – which allows the FERC to have authority to at least provide some consumer protections.
We urge our delegation to support the GRID Savings Act (S 5199)


