12 years ago, Governor Brewer’s administration and attorneys representing Arizonans with a serious mental illness reached an agreement to settle the state’s longest-running lawsuits: Arnold v. Sarn. I was the ADHS director at the time as a defendant.

Between 2011 and 2014, we put all hands on deck perform our way to a settlement rather than lawyer our way to one. That meant improving services and showing progress while negotiating an agreement that would hold future administrations accountable too.

Why Was the Case Filed?

The lawsuit began in 1981. Its central argument was simple. Arizona law required a comprehensive community mental health system for persons with a serious mental illness but ADHS and Maricopa County (and actually the state as a whole) weren’t providing it.

People with serious mental illness were going without the services needed to live safely and independently. Many were homeless or living in unregulated flophouses. As a public Fiduciary, Chick Arnold filed the initial lawsuit in Maricopa County Superior Court.

The trial court ruled against the state and county in 1986. The Arizona Supreme Court affirmed that decision in 1989. Their conclusion: that the defendants statutorily had to provide community mental health services but weren’t doing it.

Noncompliance went on for decades. There were remedial plans, more agreements, court monitoring (of questionable value) and repeated findings of noncompliance. The governor was eventually added as a defendant. People needing services continued waiting while the case remained in court.

So, What Changed in 2014?

Brewer had a keen interest in building a better system for people with serious mental illness. She held our agency accountable for improving services while simultaneously playing hardball with the Legislature to secure the funding we needed despite the recession that was finally lifting.

She expected results from ADHS and was willing to spend political capital to give us the money to achieve them. Her leadership on Medicaid restoration was essential in making it possible for us to make progress.

Throughout those years we negotiated with the plaintiffs to come up with an acceptable agreement with measurable service expectations.

Editorial note: A prerequisite to our success was suspending (ending) the court monitors – who I believe were more interested in keeping their easy gig rather than actually producing meaningful data about the performance of the system.

Standards Built Into the Settlement Agreement

As we were working through the nuts and bolts of the negotiations, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) had just developed models and assessment tools for the very services we were trying to improve.

That gave us a useful hook: we could now incorporate established standards into the agreement and use them to hold the system accountable.

The 2014 settlement agreement required adoption of SAMHSA models for four service categories:

  • Supported housing: Helping people get and keep permanent, affordable housing, with support to remain independent.
  • Assertive Community Treatment teams: Committing to coordinated treatment teams and practical support to people in their homes and communities.
  • Supported employment: Helping people find and keep regular jobs that match their interests.
  • Consumer-operated services: Recovery support led by people with lived experience called peer and family support.

These were practical and useful standards, but they weren’t perfect.

The SAHMSA models mostly focused on how services were organized and delivered: staffing, coordination, availability, and whether providers followed the model.

But they weren’t outcome standards measuring whether people maintained housing, kept a job, or avoided hospitalization or jail over time. They were more process standards (but the best we had at the time).

Following the service models doesn’t mean someone is getting the results they need. But – they were the established tools we had available and they gave us a foundation for accountability.

How Would We Know Whether It Was Working?

We built into the Settlement Agreement three ways to assess performance of the system.

  • SAMHSA fidelity reviews examine whether providers follow the models. The standards had to be incorporated into the regional behavioral health authority’s (RBHA) contracts and enforced.
  • Annual Quality Service Reviews, conducted by an independent contractor, examine whether members’ needs are identified, whether they receive services, and whether those services meet their needs. Those QSRs have been done by WICHE ever since the agreement was signed.
  • Independent service-capacity assessments to examine whether the system has enough accessible services to meet people’s needs. The agreement connected these findings to decisions about service capacity and budget recommendations. It also required public reporting and corrective action to address failures to meet SAMHSA standards.

AHCCCS (which took over all Medicaid behavioral health responsibilities from ADHS in 2015 via a sneaky budget reconciliation bill or BRB) publishes those reports on its Arnold v. Sarn webpage.

WICHE conducts the fidelity reviews; Mercer prepares the QSRs and service-capacity assessments.

There’s also a separate statutorily prepared report that AHCCCS produces each year. Here’s the 2026 Arnold v Sarn Report.

Thankfully, the Court Still Has a Role

When we reached the agreement, I agreed with the plaintiffs that the court should keep jurisdiction on the case so it could be enforced if future administrations don’t meet the benchmarks in the settlement agreement.

We wanted our commitments to survive changes in governors, agency directors, and legislative priorities.

Even today, plaintiffs can ask the court to restore the case to its active docket and enforce the agreement if defendants (AHCCCS and Maricopa County) don’t comply.

What Do the Latest Findings Tell Us?

Taken together, AHCCCS’ reports suggest a system with some strengths and weaknesses. AHCCCS’s latest report says service expansion targets have been met and all ACT providers reviewed met minimum fidelity requirements.

Mercer documents show increased use of housing and peer support housing delays, inconsistent referrals, and case-management problems remain. WICHE’s reports show spotty compliance with the intent of the settlement agreement.

I don’t have staff or specialized evaluation ability to turn these reports into a confident overall judgment about system health or settlement compliance.

But – these public reports give lawmakers, advocates, researchers, and policymakers a foundation for asking informed questions and identifying where improvement is needed.

And thanks to our important decision to leave jurisdiction with the court – if the plaintiffs believe the settlement agreement is being violated, they can still argue to the court that the case should be resurrected.