We’re coming up to crunch time for implementing the work/community engagement requirements passed by congress as H.R. 1. Actually… some stuff has already started happening (to legally present refugees and asylees).

Arizona’s First H.R. 1 Medicaid Cuts Are Here – AZ Public Health Association
Thousands of legal immigrants in Arizona are losing Medicaid| AZCentral

The changes that’ll impact more people are coming up in 9 weeks – when AHCCCS members in the expansion population (adults without dependents at home and people who earn between 100% and 138% of the federal poverty level) will need to document work, school, volunteering or other qualifying activities.

In HR1 Congress included exemptions for people with serious illnesses and disabilities. The statutory language let Kennedy write rules to implement HR1, so naturally Kennedy used that authority to write implementation rules that were restrictive as possible (e.g. kick as many people off as possible).

Basically, he wrote rules that will make people with serious illnesses and disabilities to actually prove (somehow) that their illness or disability makes is such that can’t work.

A big problem with that is how does someone ‘prove’ that? Like literally, how do you prove something like that? Would it mean that everyone with a serious illness or disability will need to get their doctor to sign a note or attestation that they can’t work?

Thankfully, Arizona joined 24 other states & DC challenging Kennedy and Oz’s unnecessarily onerous rule (technically called CMS’ Interim Final Rule).

Judge Stearns heard the oral arguments in the case last Thursday in Massachusetts. As I write this Saturday, it doesn’t look like the judge ruled yet.

Congress gave Kennedy an unusual procedural shortcut that let him write his Interim Final Rule. It lets him issue the regulation without going through the normal process under the Administrative Procedure Act.

That let Kennedy write his rules making people somehow prove their illness or disability without going through the ordinary proposed-rule process.

But… Kennedy is still subject to judicial branch review of the rule – meaning Plaintiffs can argue to the court that Kennedy exceeded his statutory authority when he made people prove (somehow) that their disability or serious illness prevents them from working.

That’s basically what the case is about (BTW AG Mayes made Arizona a party to the case).

What Does This Mean for Someone Who’s Sick?

Consider two imaginary Arizonans, Jenny and Mike. Both are 50, qualify financially for AHCCCS through Medicaid expansion population (childless adults and people between 100% and 138% of poverty). 

Jenny has Stage 3 breast cancer. She’s getting chemotherapy, with radiation planned afterward. Chemo appointments and fatigue make maintaining a regular work schedule difficult.

Under Kennedy’s rule, Jenny will have to prove (somehow) that her cancer treatment significantly impairs her ability to complete the community engagement requirement. Her medical records will show the cancer and the chemo and radiation treatment plan, but there’s no ICD code for not being able to work – so that’s not in the medical record.

If Arizona and the other blueish states succeed in removing Kennedy’s added hurdle, Jenny could qualify based on her cancer diagnosis / treatment regimen without somehow separately establishing its effect on her ability to complete the required activities.

Mike has Parkinson’s disease. His symptoms fluctuate. He can perform some things independently, but tremors, slowed movement and fatigue make sustained activity really hard. His symptoms are progressing slowly.

Under Kennedy’s rule, Mike will need to prove not just that he has Parkinson’s, but that his symptoms impair his ability to work or do the community engagement. Mike could get his doctor to document limitations that aren’t captured in existing records, but again, the doc has no ICD code or other standard way via claims etc. to document that subjective determination.

If we win, establishing his Parkinson’s diagnosis (via claims or medical records etc.) would be enough.

And Then There’s the Paperwork

If we win the case, AHCCCS will be able to verify Mike and Jenny’s exemptions using their claims data.

If Kennedy wins, these sick patients will need to somehow prove they can’t meet the community engagement requirements (via requests for clinical documentation, explanations of their functional limitations and repeated verification?).

People undergoing cancer treatment or managing a debilitating neurological disease or lots of other serious illnesses or disabilities already have enough to deal with.

Making them to repeatedly prove how sick they are adding an unnecessary and cruel burden at a difficult period in their lives… with their healthcare coverage (e.g. chemo etc.) dependent on completing the nebulous and undefined process that Kennedy wants to impose.

Shame on you Mr. Kennedy. I wonder what your dad would think? Actually, I don’t have to wonder, I know.