HR1 Doesn’t Just Harm Public Health w/ Medicaid & SNAP Cuts – It Also Increases Electricity Prices & Harms the Social Determinants of Health

The federal budget bill HR1 doesn’t just slash critical safety net programs like Medicaid and food assistance, it damages public health by dismantling the clean energy development incentives that will make electricity process even higher.

The bill ends a wide range of clean energy tax credits that have supported investment in wind, solar, and energy-efficient technologies. These credits didn’t just help homeowners go solar, they incentivized larger-scale clean energy projects that would have expanded Arizona’s electricity supply, lowered prices, and created thousands of jobs.

Now, with those incentives gone, electricity prices are set to rise faster than they otherwise would have, and lower-income households will be hit hardest.

Electricity is the second-largest household expense for low-income families, behind only rent—and it ranks higher than food. The nonpartisan Energy Innovation Policy & Technology analysis finds that, thanks to HR1, electricity prices in Arizona will increase much faster than they otherwise would have.

Electricity Price Impacts of HR1 In Arizona
Assessing Impacts Of HR1 On U.S. Energy Costs, Jobs, Health, Emissions

Here’s what’s coming because of HR1:

  • Wholesale electricity prices in Arizona are forecast to increase 18% by 2030 beyond what they otherwise would have risen, and 69% by 2035.
  • Arizona households could see $140 higher electricity bills each year by 2030, and $220 more by 2035 – that’s in addition to the hikes that would already have been projected to occur without HR1.
  • Commercial and industrial electricity users will also have price hikes; costs they will pass on to customers.

Why the increase in electricity prices under HR1? Arizona is expected to lose 10 gigawatts of electricity generation capacity by 2035 due to HR1’s rollback of clean energy tax credits. For low-income families, these rising utility bills have a ripple effect. Many will face choices between paying the rent, or keeping the A/C on, or buy groceries.

When electricity bills outpace even food costs, the social determinants of health start are harmed. Access to utilities is as vital to health as access to doctors. Losing that access through disconnection, eviction, or constant stress leads to chronic stress and mental health decline, increased risk of heat-related illness and respiratory conditions, poor developmental outcomes in children as families are forced into survival mode.

That’s capacity that would have kept prices down. Instead, utilities like APS will have every excuse to push prices even higher, especially since they at least currently have a super-compliant regulator (the ACC).

APS Rate Hikes & the Corporation Commission’s Industry Capture are Undermining Health – AZ Public Health Association

And it’s not just households that will suffer. EIPT forecasts $3.9B in lost GDP and up to 20,000 clean energy jobs lost in Arizona by 2035 due to HR1. That’s fewer employment opportunities and less economic resilience especially in rural and underserved communities.

This is a textbook case of how energy policy becomes health policy.

By stripping clean energy incentives, HR1 threatens not just our climate goals but the stability and health of Arizona families. It’s a silent crisis—until the bills come due.

HR1 SNAP Changes Presentation Hunger Summit

Now Accepting Nominations for 2025 AzPHA Public Health Awards

Thursday, October 23, 2025

5:30 – 8:30pm

435 Collective

435 S 3rd Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85003

Each year AzPHA recognizes public health professionals, health professionals and community members across Arizona who are performing extraordinary services to our community at our annual awards event. Many of our awards go back decades.

Now Accepting Nominations

for:

  • Policy Maker of the Year 
  • Senator Andy Nichols Honor Award 
  • Pete Wertheim Public Health Leadership Award 
  • Public Health Research Award 
  • Alida Montiel Indigenous Health & Advocacy Award 
  • Rising Public Health Champion 

Nominate Here: Deadline September 1, 2025

Register Today: Only $45

Includes complimentary beer, wine, soft drinks & taco bar!

US Supreme Court Dooms Federal Workforce

Last week the U.S. Supreme Court cleared the way for Kennedy and several other Secretaries to flush the federal workforce, lifting injunctions that had temporarily blocked large-scale job cuts across multiple federal agencies.

In the unsigned order, the Court determined the administration is “likely to succeed” in asserting the executive power to fire a large portion of the federal workforce without congressional approval… yet leaving unresolved the underlying legality of specific reduction plans.

The ruling gives Trump’s Secretaries the green light to fire as many people as they want  with limited judicial oversight (at least in the in the short term). The fact that they lifted the earlier injunctions suggests they have already decided the government is ‘likely to succeed’ meaning they’ve probably already made up their minds.

Standing for Science: APHA & AzPHA Push Back Against Harmful Federal Policies

The American Public Health Association has been filing lawsuits against Secretary Kennedy over recent federal decisions that threaten to undermine vaccine access (and many other things) across the United States.

AzPHA proudly supports this effort and is the first affiliate to join the inaugural class of APHA’s 1872 Society, a new donor group committed to defending science, equity, and public health infrastructure.

Secretary Kennedy’s most recent decision rolls back evidence-based vaccine recommendations and access—pose a serious threat to public health. His non-scientific, anti-vaccine stance risks reversing decades of progress in preventing disease and protecting communities.

As Public Health Comes Under Threat APHA is Taking Action

The APHA lawsuit is a necessary and courageous response. It may be the only meaningful check and balance to prevent widespread harm caused by these regressive policies.

In a letter to AzPHA this week, APHA leadership thanked us for our “deeply appreciated and critically important” contribution to the 1872 Society, which is dedicated to funding these important lawsuits. The letter emphasized how investments like ours help APHA lead “with strength and clarity” at a time when that leadership is urgently needed.

The 1872 Society was created to honor APHA’s founding year and to recognize donors who help sustain the organization’s most impactful work, including:

  • Litigation to protect public health funding and scientific integrity
  • National advocacy for fair, evidence-based policies
  • Strategic communications that combat disinformation and rebuild trust
  • Support for APHA’s core operations, which serve public health professionals across the country.
Standing Up for Public Health: How We’re Helping APHA Fight Back

As an affiliate, AzPHA is proud to stand alongside APHA in this effort. We believe these aren’t just lawsuits…  they are part of our mission and the future of our field.

We urge other affiliates, partners, and members of the public health community to join us in supporting this work of valor.

 Learn more about the lawsuit and APHA’s response to recent federal decisions:


APHA sues HHS over COVID recommendations

Public Health Heroes: Navajo County Health Department Limits Measles Exposure

Guest Blog by AzPHA Former AZPHA President Kelli Donley Williams

In early June, one of public health’s most dreaded headline’s hit the news: a local child was hospitalized with measles. Quick behind the scenes actions by a heroic team at the Navajo County Public Health Services District kept this news from becoming a statewide nightmare.

Cathy Solomon, MPH, RN, who serves as the district’s clinical services division manager and nurse epidemiologist, said a toddler who had recently traveled with family to Mexico, was transferred to Phoenix Children’s Hospital for further care after being treated at a local hospital. At PCH, the child tested positive for measles. With this news, an epidemiologist from ADHS reached out to notify Cathy’s team, who then jumped into action to protect their community.   

“Upon notification, our communicable disease team launched a full investigation. We initiated contact tracing and began assessing potential exposure locations and individuals,” Cathy said. “We provided public health guidance and strongly recommended isolation for anyone identified as having been potentially exposed during the infectious period. Coordination between our department, ADHS, and healthcare providers was key to ensuring accurate risk assessment and containment of potential secondary cases.”

How was the team able to keep the infectious disease from spreading?

“Fortunately, the family played a significant role in limiting further exposure,” she describes.  “Upon returning from their international travel, they were already aware of their potential exposure to measles and chose to self-isolate as a precautionary measure. They refrained from attending public gatherings or visiting shared spaces.

All essential items such as groceries were delivered to their home. The only public setting visited during the infectious period was an urgent care facility, and that visit was for an ear infection after the rash had resolved. This limited movement significantly reduced the risk of broader community transmission and allowed us to focus our investigation on a very narrow scope of potential contacts.”

How did Cathy and the team communicate to Navajo County citizens about measles?

“In response to the confirmed case, we issued a public service announcement through multiple channels, including our official website, social media platforms, and local print media,” she said.

“Our messaging emphasized the importance of MMR vaccination, symptoms of measles, what to do if exposed, and the measures being taken to prevent further spread. To enhance community understanding, we also produced and distributed a short educational video featuring a local pediatrician and our medical director. This video provided a reassuring and informed voice to the public and encouraged vaccination and vigilance.”

Although the team did see a modest increase in the number of individuals seeking MMR vaccine in the two weeks immediately following the campaign, Cathy said the increase was lower than anticipated considering the severity of the disease and risk of outbreak.

“This highlights the ongoing challenges we face in vaccine hesitancy and the need for sustained, proactive community education and engagement efforts beyond outbreak-related events.”

What would she recommend to other health departments who may face similar situations?
  • Early and transparent communication with state health authorities enabled rapid coordination and response.
  • Proactive self-isolation by the affected family, though voluntary, was highly effective and underscores the value of public awareness and education.
  • Targeted messaging that featured trusted local medical professionals helped lend credibility and accessibility to our public health information.
  • Internal preparedness, including having a trained communicable disease team, standardized investigation protocols, and partnerships with local media and emergency management teams, allowed for an efficient and comprehensive public health response.
    We also recommend maintaining updated community contact lists and relationships with healthcare providers to expedite communication and coordination when time is critical.

When asked who we could thank for this incredible community public health work, Cathy didn’t hesitate:

“I would like to extend my sincere appreciation to Maggie Riesop, our dedicated infectious disease nurse, who led the case investigation, performed the contact tracing, and coordinated follow-up communications with those potentially exposed.

Her thoroughness and professionalism were key to containing the incident. I would also like to thank our Emergency Management Public Information Officer (PIO) team for their swift and effective development and dissemination of public messaging, which helped keep our community informed and supported during the response.”

Bravo to all in Navajo County, at Phoenix Children’s, ADHS, and otherwise who flexed their public health muscles during this stressful time. We are thankful for your coordination, late nights, and partnership. Arizona is a healthier place because of your work!

Do you have a public health hero or program you’d like to highlight? Email details to: kellidonley@gmail.com

HR1 Guts Clean Energy & EV Incentives: Arizonans Need to Act Now to Get Tax Credits

If you’re a homeowner in Arizona thinking about going solar or buying an EV, you’ll need to get on the stick. Same thing for businesses and utilities.

While many of HR1’s cuts to safety net programs like Medicaid and food assistance won’t kick in until after the 2026 midterm elections congress made sure the elimination of clean energy incentives is immediate.

HR1 rapidly ends federal tax credits that have helped ordinary homeowners (like us, when I installed rooftop solar two years ago) afford clean energy upgrades.

We Installed a Solar Power System at Our House: This is Our Story – AZ Public Health Association

That includes a soon to expire 30% Residential Clean Energy Credit, which helped thousands of Arizonans install solar panels, batteries, and other home efficiency improvements.

That tax credit will be eliminated on December 31, 2025, with no phase-out and no grace period. To qualify for a tax credit systems must be fully installed & connected to the grid before the deadline New Years Day 2026 (not just contracted).

The timeline is even tighter for EVs. The $7,500 new EV tax credit and $4,000 used EV credit both expire on September 30, 2025.

And for businesses and utilities?

The bill strips away the long-term certainty they’d counted on as many businesses, community health centers (like Chiricahua), and utilities made plans to convert to a bigger renewable portfolio. To qualify for the Investment Tax Credit, business and utility projects must begin construction by July 4, 2026, and be connected and in service by the end of 2027.

HR1’s elimination of tax incentives to invest in clean energy will slow down but not end the conversion to renewables as the ROI for clean energy projects is rapidly becoming the least expensive way to boost power generation even without the tax credits. In addition, new solar components in panels that source less and less expensive, improving the ROI.

Note: Tariffs on solar panels from China are also impeding conversion to solar as China is a global leader in production of inexpensive solar panels. Same goes for electric vehicles – which have a 100% tariff imposed on them.

If you’ve been thinking about solar or an EV the time to act is now. With the coming ‘gold rush’ of solar installation that’ll be created by the impending end of the credits, permitting delays, installer backlogs, and supply chain snags…  you better get started NOW.

The Republican majority in Congress may have delayed politically sensitive cuts to healthcare and nutrition assistance but they’ve fast-tracked the end of clean energy support.

For Arizona households and businesses, that means making big decisions fast or losing out for who knows how long.

Kennedy Kicks Immigrants & Asylees in the Teeth

In a heartless & cruel (but not unexpected) policy shift, Secretary Kennedy declared an end to long-standing interpretation of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 – cutting off access to the already limited health and social services for immigrants and even most asylum seekers.

HHS Bans Illegal Aliens from Accessing its Taxpayer-Funded Programs | HHS.gov

The 1998 interpretation of PRWORA (crafted under the Clinton administration) had allowed for limited access to some essential services like community health centers, Head Start, and certain mental health and addiction recovery programs.

Kennedy is ending access to any and all of the already limited benefits, undercutting public health practice grounded in compassion, prevention, and pragmatism.

Denying people access to basic healthcare services, behavioral health programs, early childhood education, and family planning care is morally indefensible and harmful to our entire society.

History of Considering Public Benefits – AZ Public Health Association

His ban impacts access to Certified Community Behavioral Health Clinics, Community Mental Health Services Block Grants, Head Start, Title X Family Planning services, SAMHSA programs for substance use disorder treatment and prevention, homeless transition services, and even support for foster care and kinship placements.

These programs are lifelines not just for immigrants but for the public health system as a whole.

For example, community health centers treat infectious diseases, manage chronic illness, and ensure people (regardless of status) aren’t left to suffer or deteriorate in silence. Restricting access doesn’t make health needs disappear; it just increases suffering and shifts costs elsewhere like to emergency rooms and jails.

Immigration Status, Public Benefits, Health & Access to Care: A Primer – AZ Public Health Association

Secretary Kennedy is using the narrowest and harshest possible reading of the law.

PRWORA allowed flexibility in defining who could be served under specific exceptions for programs addressing public health emergencies, immunizations, and short-term, non-cash disaster relief.

Asylum seekers fleeing persecution are being told they can’t get mental health support or even basic health services.

Parents trying to keep their families healthy are being locked out of family planning and Head Start.

The long-term consequences? Higher rates of untreated mental illness, addiction, and preventable disease, and more children entering emergency foster placements and driving up government spending in other areas. Because undocumented folks will no longer be able to access community health centers, they’ll be stuck going to emergency departments instead, driving up expensive uncompensated care.

Note: Because Kennedy doesn’t have the authority to tell hospital emergency departments to turn away undocumented people (protected under a different law called EMTALA) he didn’t do that today… but he would have if he could have.

When some people are excluded from care, the entire community suffers. Diseases don’t ask for a green card. Addiction doesn’t care about immigration status. Denying care won’t stop people from needing it… it will only make it harder and more expensive to address later.

In short, this is yet another intentional harm from Kennedy… one that APHA will shortly be challenging in court.

Note: There’s no information yet about the details about how programs like FQHCs might implement the requirement for status verification. The policy becomes effective upon official publication in the Federal Register, expected July 11, 2025. A 30-day comment period on the notice will begin upon publication, followed by Kennedy’s rubber stamp.

AzPHA Supports Prop 409: An Important Investment in Maricopa County’s Public Health System

This fall, voters in Maricopa County will have a rare opportunity to strengthen our community’s health infrastructure by voting YES on Proposition 409.

The Arizona Public Health Association Board of Directors has already endorsed the measure, and we’re encouraging our members to join us in individually supporting this critical investment.

Valleywise Health Proposition 409 Voter Guide

Valleywise Health is Maricopa County’s only public teaching hospital and safety-net health system. Every day, it delivers trauma, burn, and behavioral health care to thousands of Arizonans, especially those with nowhere else to turn. But with our county’s population growing quickly and the need for care rising even faster, Valleywise’s aging facilities are struggling to keep up.

Proposition 409 will authorize $898M in bonds to modernize and expand the Valleywise Health system, ensuring it can continue delivering life-saving care to our most vulnerable neighbors. Specifically, Prop 409 would:

  • Double inpatient and observation capacity
  • Modernize emergency and trauma departments
  • Rebuild outdated care facilities, including the Phoenix Comprehensive Health Center
  • Expand behavioral health treatment areas
  • Upgrade training environments for tomorrow’s healthcare workforce
  • Improve access to care in underserved neighborhoods

Importantly, this bond will ensure Valleywise can continue meeting its legal obligation to conduct court-ordered mental health evaluations… an important gateway to timely behavioral health treatment.

This is a mail-in only election for Maricopa County voters, and we need strong, early engagement from the public health community. As a member of AzPHA, your individual endorsement can help elevate this once-in-a-generation opportunity to strengthen Arizona’s health system.

 Sign Up In Support of Prop 409 Here

Learn More About Prop 409

Together, we can help ensure that Valleywise Health has the tools and space it needs to keep our communities healthy, safe, and cared for.

PS: AzPHA will be submitting an argument in favor of Prop 409 in the voter publicity pamphlet – the final language of our support letter is still being revised.

See AzPHA’s Ballot Argument in Favor of Prop 409

Submit your ballot argument here